Skip to main content

Being an eco warrior has been a middle class privilege - but it doesn't have to be

 

Being able to worry about the future is a luxury. It may seem a strange statement to make, given the current state of the world. A recent art installation of a ‘Climate Clock' on a Manhattan skyscraper, a Doomsday style countdown on how long we have left to reduce our emissions enough to give Earth a 67% chance of staying below the 1.5°C of warming that scientists say is crucial to avoid catastrophic natural disasters like floods and wildfires states we have just over seven years. But this contemplation of an abstract and still preventable future peril will not be high on the list of priorities of those struggling to make it through each week. The move towards a more sustainable and considered way of life is necessary, yet it has a tendency to feel like quite a big commitment. The cost of saving the world is more than just financial - it takes time, energy and ambition.

Initially I had planned to write this piece on how unattainable this goal can feel to many people. When there are still millions of people around the world still struggling to put food on the table, and the coronavirus pandemic has left many jobs in jeopardy, how can we possibly worry about the next few decades when we're so busy worrying about next week? Yet our future is too important to be dismissed. We cannot keep delaying this issue, forever hoping someone else will pick up the slack and science will wave a magic wand to make it all disappear. We are told constantly we need to change, buy differently, be organic, don't eat meat, stop indulging in fast fashion. It's a lot to think about. 

What is starting to happen is a seemingly idealistic yet completely consumerist attitude to helping the planet; it is not only unrealistic, it is downright unfair. The lifestyle promoted by social media misinformation and greenwashing - the belief that one ought to find a green alternative to absolutely everything - is ultimately designed to sell and not to save, whether that be the environment or your wallet. Of course being rich is no prerequisite for being socially conscious, but it may not appear that way when every other Instagram post inspires a mixture of guilt and anger at our financial inability to scrub out our carbon footprint.

Organic and vegan consumption of clothes, food and toiletries does not have to be as expensive and unobtainable as it is portrayed. An achievable way forward is a lot of people doing a lot of little, simple yet effective things - for example the 5p plastic bag charge introduced only a few years ago has saved over 15 billion plastic bags from being used. The authenticity of the message of sustainable living is what is in danger of being forgotten, as laid out by Eco Warrior Princess in this insightful piece (clink on link to find). Principally we ought to make use of what we already have, rather than buying what we don't need. We need to be aware of where products and produce come from. There is no singular right way of doing this as long as you care and understand what really needs to change here.

What actually needs to be done is a filtering out of those selling an aesthetic image for profit and a move towards a total rethink of how things can be done. It is a mindset rather than a lifestyle. Wasting money on pricey clothes that will never be worn purely because they are made from organic cotton is not helping anyone, although it might massage your conscience a little next time you go clothes shopping. You can buy that new outfit from ASOS, as long as you are going to wear it enough times to make it worth the money and energy used to create it. When it comes to the weekly food shop no one is saying a 100% plant-based strictly vegan and preservative free diet will become the new norm - but maybe you could try a few meat substitutes, or shop at a local butchers? Let's be honest, people aren't going to completely ditch habits of a lifetime in the space of a few months or even seven years, but it can be easier and more effective than many believe. 

So how can we rid ourselves of the innate middle-class snobbery lurking underneath a well-intentioned initiative to save the planet? We need to be real but also optimistic; no one will bother trying if they think their efforts are already futile. There are positive changes already being implemented, as just last week Boris Johnson announced a ban on new petrol and diesel cars in the UK by 2030. Avoiding the condescension and flaunting of wealth that is in danger of defining this movement is essential, as is the fear that nothing the average person can do will make any difference. The statistic that only 100 companies are responsible for 71% of global emissions may make us feel a little better about our own contributions, but it isn't really helpful for encouraging the rest of us to act. We can all do something, and we are allowed to feel good about protecting the environment for the ones we love - even if we all know deep down vegan cheese just isn't as good as the real thing. 

 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is Progress on Diversity Heading in the Right Direction? (Pi Media)

Giving you the insight into matters directly related to student life is the Pi Comment column, Spotlight: UCL, Universities and Young People, where our team of columnists tackle the issues affecting students today. Cathy Mayer-Funnel contends with the increasingly hostile environment in the UK towards minority groups and how this is playing out in the university context. Looking around the UCL campus, one of the things that I have found most striking is the diversity embodied by our students. As someone who did their undergrad in a small city often defined by its population of predominantly white middle-class students from the Home Counties, it is somewhat refreshing to be in a seminar of only six students in which three different continents are represented. In the 2018-19 academic year there are 9,385 UK domiciled and 12, 865 non-UK domiciled  non-white  students at UCL, a significant proportion of the student body of 42,106 , while the  Equality, Diversity and...

Am I an unfriendly neighbour?

Last weekend I was waiting for a bus to take me to a doctor's appointment on my local street in North London. It was set to be the hottest day of the year so far and in preparation for this I was wearing a cropped top and shorts with flip flops (this may be an irrelevant detail but it might later enable you to understand perhaps why I was feeling a little more exposed than usual). There was one other person at the bus stop - a man of unspecified age but certainly a fair bit older than me. After some minutes had passed he told me he had been waiting a while and wasn't sure if the bus was coming. I had headphones in, which I like to think automatically give off an air of I do-not-want-to-be-disturbed ness, but I also didn't want to be completely rude so I said I would look it up on my phone and reassured him that the bus was on its way. What followed next is what troubled me. Before I launch into a potential character assassination I just want to say I have no idea if this ...

How I feel now

When I was initially coming up with ideas for this post I had intended to write a sort of lifestyle piece on how to cope with having your plans completely overhauled by the coronavirus outbreak and lockdown. But in reality I'm not sure I am in any position to tell people how they should be dealing with this, because I'm not sure I am coping. Busying myself with baking and scrapbooking, starting a new job suddenly, pouring over travel guides and planning where to go once this is over - compared to many I seem to be ploughing through. And then I find myself in the middle of my shift wanting to scream at everyone in the shop. I snap at my family for stupid reasons. I break down crying at midnight on a Thursday. Let me explain my situation a little better. Last September I completed 5 years at university, the last one spent living in London doing my masters. I moved back at home to do a gap year, supposedly spending half working and saving money, before going travelling and com...