Skip to main content

Schools reopening: why a core subject based curriculum is a mistake


red apple fruit on four pyle books

Now that a steady stream of students are starting to trickle back into school and plans are being put in place for everyone to return come September, a stripped back version of the curriculum is currently being debated. Education Secretary Gavin Williamson has insisted that this will not be the case, despite guidance from his own department suggesting that there will need to be a focus on maths and English in some areas to cover any gaps in pupil knowledge. The priority to get children back in school and back to learning is an understandable one, particularly since home schooling has proved to be somewhat challenging, to say the least. But if the push for core subjects above all else really does go ahead, we are at risk of alienating children from their education even more than COVID 19 has.

What this issue highlights is the problem with the way education is defined in our current system, and how it should be defined in an individual rather than collective sense. Like many areas of life, there is a spectrum - it isn't as simple as some children being clever and others being stupid. There are those who will always excel in academia, will likely go to university and continue on a high powered executive trajectory. Then there are others who are attracted to more vocational courses, that will become the backbone of a functioning society and will never not be in demand. Many will fall somewhere in between, perhaps needing a bit more encouragement to decide where they fit best. None of these career paths will be the same, yet they are all equally valid. So why should expect them to all have the same needs when it comes to what they learn at school?

There is no doubt that subjects such as maths, English and the sciences are important, especially where employers are concerned. They help to develop fundamental skills like problem-solving, communication and understanding how our universe works. The trouble arises when trying to engage children who struggle, either because they have learning difficulties such as dyslexia or simply because their interests don't lie in that area. By focusing on a select few subjects, there is a very real risk of isolating those children who aren't engaged by academic pursuits and require something more practical. If they do choose to implement this in schools, the Department of Education are essentially telling our students that these are the only important subjects, the only ones they need to be successful, the only ones that schools should bother with. What message does that send?

As necessary as they might be to pass exams, maths, English and science fail to enrich children in other ways that are equally beneficial. Art, music, drama, PE, technology all educate in different ways, teaching our children to express themselves, work together, create and actually do rather than just sitting behind a desk. School is supposed to prepare us for life, but even before COVID 19 it was guilty of becoming another box-ticking exercise, enabling us to regurgitate the right information in exams before we emerge bleary eyed into the 'real world'. Even those who go on to get first class degrees from the most elite universities are often confused and intimidated by this prospect. Reopening schools during a pandemic provides an opportunity to make a change, particularly given that it will still be a while before normal school life can resume. Bearing this in mind, perhaps the case can now be made for an education that isn't merely sitting in a room in front of a board. Another aim of getting our children back in school is also supposed to be getting them socialising again and bonding with their peers, actively encouraged and often essential in sports, music, drama and the like. Because if this pandemic has proved anything, it's that these qualities are the ones that keep us and our society going in times of crisis.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is Progress on Diversity Heading in the Right Direction? (Pi Media)

Giving you the insight into matters directly related to student life is the Pi Comment column, Spotlight: UCL, Universities and Young People, where our team of columnists tackle the issues affecting students today. Cathy Mayer-Funnel contends with the increasingly hostile environment in the UK towards minority groups and how this is playing out in the university context. Looking around the UCL campus, one of the things that I have found most striking is the diversity embodied by our students. As someone who did their undergrad in a small city often defined by its population of predominantly white middle-class students from the Home Counties, it is somewhat refreshing to be in a seminar of only six students in which three different continents are represented. In the 2018-19 academic year there are 9,385 UK domiciled and 12, 865 non-UK domiciled  non-white  students at UCL, a significant proportion of the student body of 42,106 , while the  Equality, Diversity and...

Am I an unfriendly neighbour?

Last weekend I was waiting for a bus to take me to a doctor's appointment on my local street in North London. It was set to be the hottest day of the year so far and in preparation for this I was wearing a cropped top and shorts with flip flops (this may be an irrelevant detail but it might later enable you to understand perhaps why I was feeling a little more exposed than usual). There was one other person at the bus stop - a man of unspecified age but certainly a fair bit older than me. After some minutes had passed he told me he had been waiting a while and wasn't sure if the bus was coming. I had headphones in, which I like to think automatically give off an air of I do-not-want-to-be-disturbed ness, but I also didn't want to be completely rude so I said I would look it up on my phone and reassured him that the bus was on its way. What followed next is what troubled me. Before I launch into a potential character assassination I just want to say I have no idea if this ...

How I feel now

When I was initially coming up with ideas for this post I had intended to write a sort of lifestyle piece on how to cope with having your plans completely overhauled by the coronavirus outbreak and lockdown. But in reality I'm not sure I am in any position to tell people how they should be dealing with this, because I'm not sure I am coping. Busying myself with baking and scrapbooking, starting a new job suddenly, pouring over travel guides and planning where to go once this is over - compared to many I seem to be ploughing through. And then I find myself in the middle of my shift wanting to scream at everyone in the shop. I snap at my family for stupid reasons. I break down crying at midnight on a Thursday. Let me explain my situation a little better. Last September I completed 5 years at university, the last one spent living in London doing my masters. I moved back at home to do a gap year, supposedly spending half working and saving money, before going travelling and com...