Skip to main content

Should STEM Subjects Overshadow Humanities? (Pi Media)

Giving you the insight into matters directly related to student life is the Pi Comment column, Spotlight: UCL, Universities and Young People, where our team of columnists the tackle issues affecting students today. With the government increasingly focusing on the importance of STEM subjects, Cathy Meyer-Funnell argues the case for the importance of Arts and Humanities in today’s increasingly technological world. 
As students at one of the world’s most prestigious universities, most of us would hope that a degree from UCL would guarantee us relatively good job prospects once we graduate. Yet for many of us a spectre remains hanging over our academic success, something that prevents us from being able to step into the world of work with total confidence – was all the work actually worth it?
As a humanities student, the recent government and industry emphasis on the importance of STEM subjects (science, technology, engineering, maths) has left me feeling as if I should have prioritised future job prospects more when picking what I wanted to study at A-Levels and university. With rapidly advancing technological developments and a world increasingly dependent on the wonders of the internet to answer any question we may have, I’m just not sure if my knowledge of the representation of female characters in the novels of Gabriel García Márquez is really going to be that sought after.
Westminster has been appealing for more people to pursue STEM subjects at university, in order for the UK economy to get the maximum benefit out of scientific progress, as well as stressing the need for those with science and technology degrees to enter politics. In 2017 only 9% of the major party candidates running for election had STEM degrees, suggesting that our current government may be worryingly ill-equipped to keep up with the constantly changing technology we have begun to rely on in our everyday lives. This in turn has lead to a skewed perspective in House of Commons debates, with the vast majority being taken up by issues such as Brexit (still undeniably a significant problem), and far fewer dedicated to equally pressing topics like climate change and cyber security.
Bearing this in mind, the need for balance on the political spectrum is clear. But should this come at the expense of more philosophical and sociological questions? And is it even right to tell students of one particular course that their studies do not matter as much as another, despite everyone having paid the same astronomically high fees and worked hard enough to get accepted into the same university?
The argument for humanities is starting to respond to this apparent favouritism of the sciences. There is an emerging fear that the rapid rate at which these technological advancements are taking place has led to some of the more ethical questions being neglected – for instance there has been little discussion regarding the effects which issues like human-robot interaction will have on society, and most of us are sadly all too familiar with the damaging consequences of an overexposure to social media. Furthermore, by placing too much emphasis on ‘education for jobs’ we risk losing out on other aspects of learning that become essential both in and outside the workplace: qualities such as compassion for others and a broader understanding of different people and cultures from around the world.
Unless you are set on a specific field, like medicine or veterinary science, the nature of your degree is generally less important than the fact you actually have one. People with a degree in history or English aren’t tied to a career as a historian or a writer, just like those who study chemistry or biology won’t necessarily end up working in a lab. The world needs people who can think, analyse, solve problems, communicate, challenge accepted norms – skills one can acquire across a range of disciplines.
I chose my degree primarily because it was what I enjoyed doing and, after all, university should be about enjoying yourself. In fact, the broadness of my subject was something that appealed to me – I studied Modern Languages – as at 17 I still had absolutely no idea what I wanted to do with my life, and I’m sure I wasn’t the only one. It meant I could still get a good degree while having a wide range of options open to me at the end of it. University is incredibly expensive and time consuming no matter what you study, so it seems pointless to waste this on a subject you hate just because you think it’s what you ought to do.
The university atmosphere has a tendency to breed competitiveness at the best of times, as students feel the pressure to get high marks, whilst simultaneously securing the best internships or graduate schemes, maintaining a social life, or even hold down a part-time job. No one should be trying to make this worse through implying that some have a harder degree and, therefore, deserve to get a better paying job as a graduate. The world needs the next generation to make it a better place, with skills tailored to meet all of its requirements.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is Progress on Diversity Heading in the Right Direction? (Pi Media)

Giving you the insight into matters directly related to student life is the Pi Comment column, Spotlight: UCL, Universities and Young People, where our team of columnists tackle the issues affecting students today. Cathy Mayer-Funnel contends with the increasingly hostile environment in the UK towards minority groups and how this is playing out in the university context. Looking around the UCL campus, one of the things that I have found most striking is the diversity embodied by our students. As someone who did their undergrad in a small city often defined by its population of predominantly white middle-class students from the Home Counties, it is somewhat refreshing to be in a seminar of only six students in which three different continents are represented. In the 2018-19 academic year there are 9,385 UK domiciled and 12, 865 non-UK domiciled  non-white  students at UCL, a significant proportion of the student body of 42,106 , while the  Equality, Diversity and...

Am I an unfriendly neighbour?

Last weekend I was waiting for a bus to take me to a doctor's appointment on my local street in North London. It was set to be the hottest day of the year so far and in preparation for this I was wearing a cropped top and shorts with flip flops (this may be an irrelevant detail but it might later enable you to understand perhaps why I was feeling a little more exposed than usual). There was one other person at the bus stop - a man of unspecified age but certainly a fair bit older than me. After some minutes had passed he told me he had been waiting a while and wasn't sure if the bus was coming. I had headphones in, which I like to think automatically give off an air of I do-not-want-to-be-disturbed ness, but I also didn't want to be completely rude so I said I would look it up on my phone and reassured him that the bus was on its way. What followed next is what troubled me. Before I launch into a potential character assassination I just want to say I have no idea if this ...

How I feel now

When I was initially coming up with ideas for this post I had intended to write a sort of lifestyle piece on how to cope with having your plans completely overhauled by the coronavirus outbreak and lockdown. But in reality I'm not sure I am in any position to tell people how they should be dealing with this, because I'm not sure I am coping. Busying myself with baking and scrapbooking, starting a new job suddenly, pouring over travel guides and planning where to go once this is over - compared to many I seem to be ploughing through. And then I find myself in the middle of my shift wanting to scream at everyone in the shop. I snap at my family for stupid reasons. I break down crying at midnight on a Thursday. Let me explain my situation a little better. Last September I completed 5 years at university, the last one spent living in London doing my masters. I moved back at home to do a gap year, supposedly spending half working and saving money, before going travelling and com...